It’s been over a year since I left NY, and now I’m going back for a quick vacation. I’m very excited to see my city, old friends and definitely all the great food. There are a group of people heading there as well who have asked where to eat while in Manhattan so I’m putting up my list of favorite places. This list is by no means comprehensive and is not meant as the “BEST” places in NYC, it is the ones I like most. I’m going to try to eat at all the places in the 4 days I’m there and see how the last year has treated them. I know for sure Tony’s is sadly gone but hopefully that’s the only change.
(You can look up the addresses on menupages.com)
Sahara on 1st Ave for Turkish It’s near 28th St and 1st Ave.
Johns on Bleecker (Pizza) - Bleecker btwn 6th and 7thAve
(Bleeker is the street just south of W3rd)
Lombardis (Pizza) - Soho, Prince st near Mott I believe
For just a slice (the top 2 are whole pie places only), you can go to the place on the corner of 7thAve and Bleeker, I forget the name, but it’s right on the corner and get the Nonna Maria slice. Good for a west village snack.
Sullivan St. Bakery (Breadish Pizza) - if you’re shopping in Soho, hit this place for a bread snack.
Mamouns (Falafel, Schwarma), but I also like the place across the street, I think it’s called Ali Baba, they have pickles you can put on your falafel.
Pylos (Greek) on 6th I think, between 1st and Ave A, a sit down restaurant with great decor.
If you want fancy, go to Gramercy tavern one night, eat in the front room not the back room, but it’s pretty expensive.
For Sushi, hit Tomoe, on Thompson btwn bleeker and Houston, but be ready for a line at dinner time.
Right next to it is Lupa, Mario Battali’s rustic italian (not red sauce) less upscale place, but good in my opinion. Again, very likely a wait.
Katz deli on Houston, just past Ave A, Orchard. Huge sandwiches, I love the pastrami, but they have other stuff too. Overpriced but a must go for the Harry met Sally nostalgia.
If you like knitches, go to the place next to Russ and Daughters, whose name I’m forgetting, it’s famous, just ask and people will know.
If you’re going to a broadway show, you can go to Becco for all you can eat pasta that Jaime says is good, though I have never tried it. Or you can try the John’s Pizza near Times Sq, around 45th St and 7th
If for some reason you’re in midtown on the east side (which you really shouldn’t be unless you’re going to see the UN) go to Tony’s and get a parmagian sandwich (susage, chiken, meatball), on 2nd Ave btwn 42nd and 43rd. I don’t think this one is even on menupages, but one of the best damn sandwiches in the city.
Dessert:
Bruno’s on Laguardia btwn Bleeker and Houston, mmmm chocolate mousse.
Canoli = Rocco’s, Bleeker btwn 6th and 7th, very close to 6th Ave.
Cones (right next to Johns pizza) on Bleeker has good gelato, argentinian styke.
Laboratoria de Gelato is unbelievable, but it’ll be hard for you to find and it’s in the LES, kind of out of the way for most tourists, but well worth the trek.
In that same vein, doughnut planet is a good diversion.
That should be enough to get you started, there’s so many more, it’s tiring to write. I’m sure I’m forgetting a lot too and you’ll find your own hidden gems as well.